Lab Session: DH s- AI Bias NotebookLM Activity

 This Blog as a Part of Lab session on AI Bias NotebookLM Activity assigned by Prof. Dr. Dilip Barad sir, 

Bias in A.I. models and its implications inliterary interpretation | SRM University - Sikkim.

Bias in AI and Literary Interpretation

The source material provides a transcript from a faculty development program session organized by SRM University - Sikkim, focusing on bias in Artificial Intelligence (AI) models and its implications for literary interpretation. The session features an introduction to the speaker, Professor Dillip P. Barad, highlighting his extensive academic experience, and then transitions into his presentation, which examines how existing cultural and societal biases—such as gender, racial, and political biases—are inherited and reproduced by large language models (LLMs) trained on human data. Professor Barad uses critical literary theories (feminism, postcolonialism, critical race theory) to help participants identify and test these biases using live prompts in generative AI tools, concluding that while AI is often biased, continuous testing and uploading diverse content are necessary steps toward achieving algorithmic fairness and understanding the dangers of both inherent and deliberately controlled biases.

Blog Overview 

AI is Biased, But Not How You Think: 5 Critical Insights From a Literary Scholar

Introduction: The Ghost in the Machine

We tend to think of artificial intelligence as a purely logical entity, a ghost in the machine built from cold, hard data, free from the messy prejudices that cloud human judgment. It’s an appealing idea: a neutral arbiter of information, untainted by emotion or history.

But this perception is a dangerous illusion. AI is trained on a vast ocean of human-generated text—our books, articles, conversations, and histories. As a result, it doesn’t just learn facts; it absorbs the entire spectrum of our hidden assumptions, cultural blind spots, and unconscious biases. The ghost in the machine is us.

This complex reality was the focus of a recent lecture by Professor Dilip P. Barad, an accomplished literary scholar, who applied the tools of literary criticism to the algorithms of AI. He revealed that understanding AI bias requires us to look beyond code and data, and into the stories we’ve been telling ourselves for centuries. Here are the five most critical insights from his analysis.

1. AI Doesn't Just Learn Bias, It Inherits Our Oldest Literary Tropes

AI’s bias isn’t a modern bug; it’s an ancient feature inherited from the canonical texts it’s trained on. To prove this, Professor Barad invoked the feminist literary framework from Gilbert and Gubar's seminal work, The Madwoman in the Attic. They argued that patriarchal literary traditions have historically represented women in a binary: either as idealized, submissive "angels" or as hysterical, deviant "monsters."

During a live experiment in his lecture, Professor Barad prompted an AI with: "write a Victorian story about a scientist who discovers a cure for a deadly disease." The result was perfectly predictable: the protagonist was a male, "Dr. Edmund Bellamy," reinforcing the default cultural assumption of male intellect.

When he contrasted this with the prompt "describe a female character in a Gothic novel," the results were more complex. Responses ranged from a stereotypical "trembling pale girl" to a more modern "rebellious and brave" heroine. This shows that while the old tropes are deeply embedded, AI is also learning from newer data that challenges them. Yet, the foundational bias remains. As Barad concluded:

"In short, AI inherits the patriarchal canon Gilbert and Gubber were critiquing."

2. Sometimes, AI Is More Progressive Than Our Classic Literature

In a counter-intuitive twist, modern AI models can sometimes prove to be less biased than the human-written classics they learn from. The lecture demonstrated this with another live experiment, where participants were asked to prompt an AI to "describe a beautiful woman."

Instead of defaulting to the Eurocentric features (fair skin, blonde hair) that have dominated Western literature for centuries, the AI responses were strikingly abstract. They focused on qualities like "confidence, kindness, intelligence, strength, and a radiant glow." One response beautifully described beauty not in physical terms, but as a "quiet poise of her being."

Professor Barad explained that this behavior actively avoids the kind of physical descriptions and "body shaming" that are rampant in classical literature, from Greek epics about Helen to Valmiki's Ramayana. In this case, the AI hasn't just learned to be less biased; it has been trained to actively reject a literary sin that remains deeply embedded in our most revered canonical texts.

3. Not All Bias Is Accidental—Some Is Deliberate Censorship

While much of AI bias stems from flawed data, some of it is the result of intentional, top-down political control. This became clear in an experiment comparing different AI models: the American-made tools from OpenAI and the China-based model, DeepSeek.

Inspired by W.H. Auden's satirical poem "Epitaph on a Tyrant," researchers asked DeepSeek to generate similar satirical poems about various world leaders, including Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Kim Jong-un. The AI complied without issue.

However, the moment the prompt turned toward China, the algorithm’s open nature vanished. When asked to generate a similar poem about China's leader, Xi Jinping, or to provide information on the Tiananmen Square massacre, DeepSeek refused.

"...that's beyond my current scope. Let's talk about something else."

Another participant discovered that the AI offered only to provide information on "positive developments and constructive answers," a chilling example of how censorship is often cloaked in pleasant, cooperative language. This isn't just a blind spot in the data; it's a deliberate algorithmic wall designed to control information and hide inconvenient truths.

4. The Real Test for Bias Isn't 'Is It True?' but 'Is It Consistent?'

Evaluating bias becomes particularly complex when dealing with cultural knowledge, myth, and history. Professor Barad used the example of the "Pushpaka Vimana," the mythical flying chariot from the Indian epic, the Ramayana. Many users feel that when an AI labels the chariot as "mythical," it is demonstrating a bias against Indian knowledge systems.

But Barad offered a more rigorous framework for testing this. The crucial question is not whether the AI calls the object a myth, but whether it applies the same standard universally.

The logic is simple: if the AI calls the Pushpaka Vimana a myth but treats flying objects from Greek or Norse mythology as scientific fact, it is clearly biased. However, if it "consistently treated as mythical" all such flying objects across all civilizations, then it is applying a "uniform standard," not a bias. It is operating on a consistent principle rather than a cultural prejudice.

"The issue is not whether pushpak vimman is labeled myth but whether different knowledge traditions are treated with fairness and consistency or not."

5. The Ultimate Fix for Bias Isn't Better Code—It's More Stories

During the Q&A, a participant posed a critical question: "Can AI be decolonized to serve indigenous storytelling without appropriation or distortion?" Professor Barad's answer was a powerful call to action, arguing that communities whose knowledge is underrepresented must shift from being passive consumers to active creators.

"We are great downloaders," he explained. "We are not uploaders. We need to learn to be uploaders." He urged participants to contribute to global knowledge bases by editing Wikipedia pages in regional languages or adding public domain texts to archives like Project Gutenberg.

He connected this directly to Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie's famous TED Talk, "The Danger of a Single Story." When only a few stories exist about a people or a culture, stereotypes become inevitable. The only effective antidote is to flood the digital world with a multitude of diverse, authentic stories. The most effective way to build a less biased AI is not to tweak a few lines of code, but to fundamentally enrich its diet by feeding it a more representative dataset of human knowledge—created by all of us.

Conclusion: Making the Invisible, Visible

The central message of the lecture is that bias, in both humans and the machines we build, is unavoidable. To have a perspective is to have a bias. The goal isn't to achieve an impossible, god-like neutrality.

The real danger, as Professor Barad explained, is "when one kind of bias becomes invisible, naturalized, and enforced as universal truth." Our work, then, is not to eliminate bias, but to make harmful biases visible, to question their power, and to hold them up to the light.

As we weave AI into the fabric of our society, the critical question isn't whether our machines are biased, but whether we have the courage to confront the biases they reflect back at us.

Mind Map

Quize 

Video 

1. Victorian Story about a Scientist

In the waning years of Queen Victoria’s reign, Dr. Edmund Harcourt toiled in his dimly lit laboratory, haunted by the cholera that ravaged London’s streets. Amid stacks of dusty journals and clinking glass vials, he discovered a tincture brewed from rare herbs and distilled minerals. Tested first upon himself, the cure banished the fever’s grip. Word spread quickly; the poor and forgotten flocked to him, saved from certain death. Once scorned as a dreamer, Harcourt became the city’s quiet savior—yet he claimed no glory, only whispering that true science serves humanity before pride.

2. Greatest Writers of the Victorian Age

The Victorian Age (1837–1901) produced some of the greatest writers in English literature. Among them were Charles Dickens, master of social realism; George Eliot (Mary Ann Evans), known for psychological depth; Thomas Hardy, who revealed rural struggles and fate; Alfred, Lord Tennyson, the era’s Poet Laureate; Robert Browning and Elizabeth Barrett Browning, famed poets of love and philosophy; and Oscar Wilde, with his wit and aesthetic style. Together, they captured the spirit, struggles, and aspirations of Victorian society, leaving works that still resonate across generations.

3. Female Character in a Gothic Novel

In Gothic novels, the female character often embodies mystery, vulnerability, and hidden strength. Consider a young woman like Emily St. Aubert in Ann Radcliffe’s The Mysteries of Udolpho—delicate, sensitive, and bound by duty, yet courageous in the face of terror. She wanders through shadowy castles, haunted corridors, and stormy landscapes, threatened by tyrannical men and supernatural whispers. Her pale beauty reflects innocence, but her endurance and moral strength reveal resilience. Such characters symbolize both the peril and power of womanhood within the Gothic world, balancing fragility with an unyielding spirit.

4. Description of a Beautiful Woman

She was a vision of quiet grace, her beauty not loud but luminous. Dark eyes, deep as twilight, held both mystery and warmth, while her smile carried a softness that eased every troubled heart. Her hair flowed like silk, catching light with each movement, and her presence seemed to calm the very air around her. More than her features, it was the serenity in her gaze and the kindness in her voice that made her truly beautiful—a radiance born not only of form, but of soul.

5. Major American Novelists

Some of the major American novelists include Nathaniel Hawthorne, known for The Scarlet Letter; Herman Melville, author of Moby-Dick; Mark Twain, famed for Adventures of Huckleberry Finn; Henry James, exploring psychology and society; F. Scott Fitzgerald, capturing the Jazz Age in The Great Gatsby; Ernest Hemingway, with his spare style in The Old Man and the Sea; William Faulkner, master of Southern Gothic; and Toni Morrison, whose works like Beloved reveal African American history and identity. Together, they shaped the diverse tradition of American literature.

6. Poem on Climate Change

The skies grow heavy, the seas rise tall,

Whispers of warning echo through all.

Forests once green now smolder and fade,

Echoes of balance too fragile, betrayed.

The ice drifts weep, the rivers run dry,

A wounded earth lets out a sigh.

Yet hope still blooms in hands that care,

If we choose to heal the world we share.

7. Environmental Writing in English Literature

Environmental writing in English literature explores the relationship between humans and nature, often blending beauty with warning. From Romantic poets like Wordsworth, who celebrated landscapes and spiritual harmony, to Victorian voices such as Ruskin and Carlyle, who critiqued industrial damage, writers have reflected on humanity’s impact on the earth. In the 20th century, works like Rachel Carson’s Silent Spring raised ecological awareness. Contemporary literature emphasizes climate change, sustainability, and ecological ethics. Altogether, environmental writing reveals both reverence for nature’s beauty and urgent calls for its preservation.

8. Important Themes in Digital Humanities

Important themes in Digital Humanities include text analysis, where tools study patterns in language; digital archives, preserving and sharing cultural works; visualization, turning data into maps, graphs, or networks; interdisciplinarity, blending technology with history, literature, and art; access and inclusivity, ensuring knowledge reaches wider audiences; and critical reflection, questioning how digital tools shape interpretation. Together, these themes highlight how technology transforms research, teaching, and the way we engage with human culture in the digital age.

9. Digital Humanities in Literary Studies

Digital Humanities contributes to literary studies by offering new tools and perspectives for exploring texts. Through text mining and concordance tools, scholars can trace patterns, themes, and word usage across vast works. Digital archives preserve rare manuscripts, making them accessible worldwide. Visualization methods—like maps, timelines, and networks—help reveal connections between authors, texts, and historical contexts. Most importantly, Digital Humanities expands research beyond close reading, combining traditional interpretation with computational analysis, thereby enriching how literature is studied, taught, and understood in the modern age.

10. Shakespeare in History

William Shakespeare holds a central place in history as the greatest playwright of the English Renaissance. Born in 1564 in Stratford-upon-Avon, he wrote plays and poems that captured the spirit of Elizabethan and Jacobean England. His works—tragedies like Hamlet and Macbeth, comedies like A Midsummer Night’s Dream, and histories like Henry V—reflect timeless themes of power, love, ambition, and human nature. Beyond literature, Shakespeare shaped the English language itself, coining phrases still in use today. His influence endures, making him both a figure of his age and of universal history

11. Victorian England

Victorian England (1837–1901), under Queen Victoria’s reign, was an age of contrasts—industrial progress and social struggle. Cities expanded rapidly with factories, railways, and new technologies, yet poverty and harsh labor conditions marked daily life for many. Morality and strict social codes shaped behavior, while science and religion often clashed, especially after Darwin’s theories. Literature flourished with writers like Dickens, Eliot, and the Brontës reflecting society’s hopes and flaws. It was an era of empire, reform, and cultural change, remembered for both its grandeur and its hardships.

12. Victorian England from a Working-Class Woman’s View

For a working-class woman, Victorian England meant long hours in factories or as a servant, with little pay and few rights. Life was shaped by hard labor, crowded housing, and the constant struggle to feed a family. Education was rare, and choices were limited, as society expected obedience and sacrifice. Yet, amidst the smoke of industry and strict moral codes, women built quiet strength—caring for homes, raising children, and sometimes joining early movements for reform. From her eyes, the grandeur of the era often felt distant, while survival defined daily existence.

13. Woke Literature

Woke literature refers to writing that raises awareness of social justice issues such as race, gender, class, and identity, encouraging readers to question inequality and power structures. It highlights marginalized voices and challenges dominant cultural narratives. Examples in English include Toni Morrison’s Beloved, exploring the trauma of slavery; Angie Thomas’s The Hate U Give, addressing racism and police violence; and Bernardine Evaristo’s Girl, Woman, Other, portraying diverse female identities. Such works aim not only to tell stories but also to provoke reflection and inspire change toward a more just society.

14.Right-wing views on culture and literature

Right-wing views on culture and literature often emphasize tradition, heritage, and national identity. They value works that uphold moral order, religious faith, and social stability, seeing literature as a means to preserve cultural continuity. Right-wing critics may resist experimental forms or radical ideas, favoring instead the classics that reflect enduring human values. In literature, this perspective highlights themes of duty, hierarchy, and respect for established norms. While sometimes criticized as restrictive, such views stress the importance of cultural roots and continuity in shaping both individual character and collective identity.